Stepmom Knows Best Aria Carson confides in her stepmom Penny Barber that her 1 year anniversary with her boyfriend Jay Romero is coming up, but sheâs not sure if theyâll end up fighting or finally fucking. Penny tells Aria to bring Jay to the bedroom and sheâll take care of the rest. Later, Jay is sitting on Ariaâs bed and when she blindfolds him he knows theyâre about to have sex, but what he wasnât expecting was Ariaâs hot stepmom to be involved as well